Heroes of Might and Magic Community
visiting hero! Register | Today's Posts | Games | Search! | FAQ/Rules | AvatarList | MemberList | Profile


Age of Heroes Headlines:  
5 Oct 2016: Heroes VII development comes to an end.. - read more
6 Aug 2016: Troubled Heroes VII Expansion Release - read more
26 Apr 2016: Heroes VII XPack - Trial by Fire - Coming out in June! - read more
17 Apr 2016: Global Alternative Creatures MOD for H7 after 1.8 Patch! - read more
7 Mar 2016: Romero launches a Piano Sonata Album Kickstarter! - read more
19 Feb 2016: Heroes 5.5 RC6, Heroes VII patch 1.7 are out! - read more
13 Jan 2016: Horn of the Abyss 1.4 Available for Download! - read more
17 Dec 2015: Heroes 5.5 update, 1.6 out for H7 - read more
23 Nov 2015: H7 1.4 & 1.5 patches Released - read more
31 Oct 2015: First H7 patches are out, End of DoC development - read more
5 Oct 2016: Heroes VII development comes to an end.. - read more
[X] Remove Ads
LOGIN:     Username:     Password:         [ Register ]
New Server | HOMM1: info forum | HOMM2: info forum | HOMM3: info forum | HOMM4: info forum | HOMM5: info forum | MMH6: wiki forum | MMH7: wiki forum
Heroes Community > Age of Heroes Coliseum > Thread: ICTC Proposals Average Score
Thread: ICTC Proposals Average Score This thread is 2 pages long: 1 2 · NEXT»
JJ_The_Ripper
JJ_The_Ripper


Adventuring Hero
addicted HOMM player
posted February 06, 2006 05:21 PM bonus applied.
Edited by JJ_The_Ripper on 20 Feb 2006

ICTC Proposals Average Score

To make it easier to anyone follow the scores for the different towns, I created this thread showing the average values for each proposal.
I will update it ONCE a day.
Panduwana, I took the liberty to use your list
With best regards, JJ.

UPDATED! Finished!
I also included rankings to each item (Votes, Race, History, Creatures, Balance, and Originality).


Legend:
V = Votes
R = Race
H = History
C = Creatures
B = Balance
O = Originality
Score = Average score

ICTC Proposals Average

Abyss - Foonlegacy
V(16) R:7,46 H:6,89 C:7,14 B:5,89 O:6,14
Score: 33,53/50

Aesir (Kingdom of North) - kdahl
V(1) R:3,00 H:0,00 C:0,00 B:0,00 O:0,00
Score: 03,00/50

Amatsu - orbvius
V(9) R:7,03 H:7,87 C:7,20 B:6,37 O:8,42
Score: 36,89/50

Arctic Town - Gerdash
V(12) R:6,08 H:2,08 C:6,38 B:5,92 O:6,71
Score: 27,17/50

Artic Town - TheNordicKing
V(9) R:7,29 H:5,62 C:7,18 B:6,90 O:6,34
Score: 33,33/50

Assaeroth - Shylock
V(7) R:6,36 H:7,65 C:6,22 B:5,51 O:6,97
Score: 32,71/50

Asylum - Cheshire_Cat
V(7) R:5,94 H:4,51 C:6,09 B:6,80 O:5,66
Score: 29,00/50

Atlantis - gwyndolium
V(10) R:7,38 H:6,38 C:7,28 B:6,28 O:7,38
Score: 34,70/50

Azurin - AngelKiller
V(9) R:7,47 H:5,91 C:6,69 B:6,47 O:6,13
Score: 32,67/50

Barren Dunes - Lord_Pc
V(5) R:5,60 H:4,20 C:5,80 B:6,00 O:6,20
Score: 27,80/50

Bastion - BoogieMan
V(10) R:8,11 H:7,41 C:8,11 B:8,01 O:7,71
Score: 39,35/50

Beast-Alliance - Oakwarrior
V(25) R:8,06 H:8,22 C:7,86 B:8,22 O:7,86
Score: 40,24/50

Blood - godstuffus
V(10) R:7,37 H:4,92 C:7,87 B:6,82 O:7,12
Score: 34,10/50

Burrows - Frakel
V(10) R:7,56 H:7,36 C:7,71 B:7,01 O:7,36
Score: 37,00/50

Cavern - kookastar
V(8) R:7,28 H:7,15 C:8,03 B:7,03 O:8,65
Score: 38,13/50

Civilization of the Deep - MasterSandro
V(14) R:6,73 H:6,66 C:7,23 B:7,01 O:8,01
Score: 35,64/50

Colony - DukeAchillus
V(4) R:5,40 H:3,15 C:6,40 B:6,90 O:7,15
Score: 29,00/50

Community - Blitzkrieg_Boy
V(2) R:7,00 H:2,50 C:9,00 B:9,00 O:9,00
Score: 36,50/50

Confederation - diomed
V(7) R:6,43 H:5,14 C:7,71 B:6,57 O:8,14
Score: 34,00/50

Cult - Lord-Kilburn
V(6) R:7,93 H:7,77 C:6,93 B:7,43 O:7,77
Score: 37,83/50

Demonificants - pug_1984
V(4) R:5,00 H:5,25 C:4,25 B:4,00 O:5,25
Score: 23,75/50

Den - joe
V(4) R:6,75 H:5,25 C:6,50 B:7,00 O:7,25
Score: 32,75/50

Dinosaurians - sidtrix
V(1) R:3,00 H:0,00 C:5,00 B:0,00 O:3,00
Score: 11,00/50

Dwarven Mine - zombielordzero
V(8) R:5,13 H:6,50 C:5,00 B:5,75 O:5,50
Score: 27,88/50

Engineers - kdahl
V(2) R:0,00 H:0,00 C:0,25 B:0,00 O:5,25
Score: 05,50/50

Forge - godstuffus
V(4) R:6,50 H:3,00 C:5,75 B:6,75 O:8,00
Score: 30,00/50

Fortress - NightFalcon
V(2) R:4,50 H:3,00 C:4,00 B:5,50 O:4,50
Score: 21,50/50

Glacier - Baklava
V(7) R:6,97 H:7,83 C:7,54 B:6,97 O:6,97
Score: 36,29/50

High Mountanins - caostotal_2000
V(8) R:8,10 H:7,72 C:7,47 B:5,72 O:7,85
Score: 36,88/50

High Wind Clan - admira
V(13) R:6,31 H:6,38 C:7,54 B:6,46 O:7,38
Score: 34,08/50

Hive - UruramTururam
V(8) R:7,13 H:5,50 C:7,13 B:6,38 O:8,13
Score: 34,25/50

Hollow - Kongo_Team
V(8) R:8,13 H:7,63 C:7,88 B:7,25 O:7,75
Score: 38,63/50

Horde - godstuffus
V(4) R:6,25 H:5,00 C:7,00 B:7,75 O:5,75
Score: 31,75/50

Hylozium - neko
V(9) R:6,89 H:6,89 C:6,78 B:6,33 O:8,67
Score: 35,56/50

Hyphae - Freeze_Dried
V(3) R:5,00 H:4,67 C:6,00 B:7,00 O:7,33
Score: 30,00/50

Imperial - Ulf
V(6) R:6,83 H:6,50 C:7,00 B:7,67 O:7,17
Score: 35,17/50

Island - FriendOfGunnar
V(9) R:7,73 H:8,29 C:7,51 B:6,40 O:8,40
Score: 38,33/50

NarMai - Edenfer
V(10) R:7,31 H:7,86 C:7,61 B:6,11 O:8,51
Score: 37,40/50

Nomads - kdahl
V(1) R:0,00 H:0,00 C:0,00 B:0,00 O:1,00
Score: 01,00/50

Oasis - rafanest
V(5) R:4,20 H:4,00 C:6,60 B:6,80 O:6,00
Score: 27,60/50

Order of Sun - NightFalcon
V(6) R:5,00 H:5,00 C:6,33 B:6,50 O:6,17
Score: 29,00/50

Palace - Crashnburn
V(5) R:3,80 H:1,00 C:5,60 B:6,40 O:6,20
Score: 23,00/50

Permafrost - koshde
V(13) R:6,37 H:5,45 C:7,52 B:7,06 O:7,37
Score: 33,77/50

Planars - JortoBadfingrs
V(4) R:5,50 H:0,00 C:6,00 B:6,75 O:6,50
Score: 24,75/50

Roost - dragonlord5555
V(2) R:0,50 H:2,50 C:0,50 B:0,50 O:0,50
Score: 04,50/50

Sanctuary - Blitzkrieg_Boy
V(13) R:7,66 H:7,12 C:7,70 B:6,16 O:7,89
Score: 36,54/50

Saurian - Gnoll_Mage
V(9) R:7,94 H:5,72 C:7,94 B:8,28 O:7,17
Score: 37,06/50

Seerhome - fortress_fan
V(7) R:6,31 H:6,03 C:6,31 B:6,60 O:5,89
Score: 31,14/50

Shiro - Delf
V(5) R:6,62 H:6,82 C:6,92 B:6,12 O:7,12
Score: 33,60/50

Shrine - godstuffus
V(6) R:6,50 H:5,50 C:6,83 B:7,17 O:7,50
Score: 33,50/50

Stoneblood - TitaniumAlloy
V(5) R:7,00 H:6,40 C:7,20 B:5,60 O:6,60
Score: 32,80/50

Stronghold - Gnoll_Mage
V(8) R:6,25 H:4,88 C:8,00 B:8,13 O:6,75
Score: 34,00/50

Stronghold (by TDL) - TDL
V(7) R:8,00 H:6,43 C:6,71 B:7,57 O:7,43
Score: 36,14/50

Stronghold of The North - rldragon
V(8) R:8,00 H:8,00 C:7,63 B:7,38 O:6,88
Score: 37,88/50

Swamp - Vinius
V(8) R:4,75 H:4,38 C:5,50 B:6,50 O:4,13
Score: 25,25/50

Temple of Light - theprawito
V(5) R:3,64 H:3,84 C:4,84 B:5,04 O:3,64
Score: 21,00/50

Thaumaturges - molechular
V(6) R:6,92 H:3,67 C:7,17 B:6,00 O:7,25
Score: 31,00/50

Thundercrack - Phoenixzs
V(13) R:7,11 H:5,80 C:6,88 B:6,42 O:6,72
Score: 32,92/50

Tinkers - Gredinus
V(6) R:4,33 H:2,33 C:5,17 B:5,67 O:8,00
Score: 25,50/50

Tomb - JJ_The_Ripper
V(9) R:7,49 H:7,93 C:7,16 B:7,27 O:7,27
Score: 37,11/50

Vocanos Rage - Pyromanzer
V(3) R:1,00 H:1,33 C:2,67 B:2,67 O:3,67
Score: 11,33/50

Vykavinco - Lord_Pc
V(9) R:6,56 H:7,00 C:7,00 B:6,33 O:7,78
Score: 34,67/50

Warp - bloodandhonor
V(11) R:6,55 H:6,82 C:6,82 B:6,55 O:7,64
Score: 34,36/50

Wild - darkss
V(6) R:6,33 H:7,67 C:6,50 B:7,83 O:6,17
Score: 34,50/50

Wilderness - ManiaCCC
V(1) R:2,00 H:2,00 C:2,00 B:2,00 O:2,00
Score: 10,00/50

Ziggurat - War-overlord
V(6) R:8,80 H:7,97 C:8,47 B:7,47 O:8,97
Score: 41,67/50

Ranking List

Position - Score - Town - Author

01 - 41,67 - Ziggurat - War-overlord
02 - 40,24 - Beast-Alliance - Oakwarrior
03 - 39,35 - Bastion - BoogieMan
04 - 38,63 - Hollow - Kongo_Team
05 - 38,33 - Island - FriendOfGunnar
06 - 38,13 - Cavern - kookastar
07 - 37,88 - Stronghold of The North - rldragon
08 - 37,83 - Cult - Lord-Kilburn
09 - 37,40 - NarMai - Edenfer
10 - 37,11 - Tomb - JJ_The_Ripper
11 - 37,06 - Saurian - Gnoll_Mage
12 - 37,00 - Burrows - Frakel
13 - 36,89 - Amatsu - orbvius
14 - 36,88 - High Mountanins - caostotal_2000
15 - 36,54 - Sanctuary - Blitzkrieg_Boy
16 - 36,50 - Community - Blitzkrieg_Boy
17 - 36,29 - Glacier - Baklava
18 - 36,14 - Stronghold (by TDL) - TDL
19 - 35,64 - Civilization of the Deep - MasterSandro
20 - 35,56 - Hylozium - neko
21 - 35,17 - Imperial - Ulf
22 - 34,70 - Atlantis - gwyndolium
23 - 34,67 - Vykavinco - Lord_Pc
24 - 34,50 - Wild - darkss
25 - 34,36 - Warp - bloodandhonor
26 - 34,25 - Hive - UruramTururam
27 - 34,10 - Blood - godstuffus
28 - 34,08 - High Wind Clan - admira
29 - 34,00 - Stronghold - Gnoll_Mage
30 - 34,00 - Confederation - diomed
31 - 33,77 - Permafrost - koshde
32 - 33,60 - Shiro - Delf
33 - 33,53 - Abyss - Foonlegacy
34 - 33,50 - Shrine - godstuffus
35 - 33,33 - Artic Town - TheNordicKing
36 - 32,92 - Thundercrack - Phoenixzs
37 - 32,80 - Stoneblood - TitaniumAlloy
38 - 32,75 - Den - joe
39 - 32,71 - Assaeroth - Shylock
40 - 32,67 - Azurin - AngelKiller
41 - 31,75 - Horde - godstuffus
42 - 31,14 - Seerhome - fortress_fan
43 - 31,00 - Thaumaturges - molechular
44 - 30,00 - Hyphae - Freeze_Dried
45 - 30,00 - Forge - godstuffus
46 - 29,00 - Asylum - Cheshire_Cat
47 - 29,00 - Order of Sun - NightFalcon
48 - 29,00 - Colony - DukeAchillus
49 - 27,88 - Dwarven Mine - zombielordzero
50 - 27,80 - Barren Dunes - Lord_Pc
51 - 27,60 - Oasis - rafanest
52 - 27,17 - Arctic Town - Gerdash
53 - 25,50 - Tinkers - Gredinus
54 - 25,25 - Swamp - Vinius
55 - 24,75 - Planars - JortoBadfingrs
56 - 23,75 - Demonificants - pug_1984
57 - 23,00 - Palace - Crashnburn
58 - 21,50 - Fortress - NightFalcon
59 - 21,00 - Temple of Light - theprawito
60 - 11,33 - Vocanos Rage - Pyromanzer
61 - 11,00 - Dinosaurians - sidtrix
62 - 10,00 - Wilderness - ManiaCCC
63 - 05,50 - Engineers - kdahl
64 - 04,50 - Roost - dragonlord5555
65 - 03,00 - Aesir (Kingdom of North) - kdahl
66 - 01,00 - Nomads - kdahl

Position - Votes - Town - Author

01 - 25 - Beast-Alliance - Oakwarrior
02 - 16 - Abyss - Foonlegacy
03 - 14 - Civilization of the Deep - MasterSandro
04 - 13 - Sanctuary - Blitzkrieg_Boy
05 - 13 - Thundercrack - Phoenixzs
06 - 13 - Permafrost - koshde
07 - 13 - High Wind Clan - admira
08 - 12 - Arctic Town - Author - Gerdash
09 - 11 - Warp - bloodandhonor
10 - 10 - Bastion - BoogieMan
11 - 10 - Burrows - Frakel
12 - 10 - Atlantis - gwyndolium
13 - 10 - Blood - godstuffus
14 - 10 - NarMai - Edenfer
15 - 9 - Saurian - Gnoll_Mage
16 - 9 - Island - FriendOfGunnar
17 - 9 - Tomb - JJ_The_Ripper
18 - 9 - Azurin - AngelKiller
19 - 9 - Artic Town - Author - TheNordicKing
20 - 9 - Amatsu - orbvius
21 - 9 - Hylozium - neko
22 - 9 - Vykavinco - Lord_Pc
23 - 8 - Hollow - Kongo_Team
24 - 8 - High Mountanins - caostotal_2000
25 - 8 - Stronghold of The North - rldragon
26 - 8 - Cavern - kookastar
27 - 8 - Hive - UruramTururam
28 - 8 - Stronghold - Gnoll_Mage
29 - 8 - Dwarven Mine - zombielordzero
30 - 8 - Swamp - Vinius
31 - 7 - Stronghold (by TDL) - TDL
32 - 7 - Glacier - Baklava
33 - 7 - Confederation - diomed
34 - 7 - Assaeroth - Shylock
35 - 7 - Seerhome - fortress_fan
36 - 7 - Asylum - Cheshire_Cat
37 - 6 - Ziggurat - War-overlord
38 - 6 - Cult - Lord-Kilburn
39 - 6 - Thaumaturges - molechular
40 - 6 - Imperial - Ulf
41 - 6 - Shrine - godstuffus
42 - 6 - Wild - darkss
43 - 6 - Order of Sun - NightFalcon
44 - 6 - Tinkers - Gredinus
45 - 5 - Stoneblood - TitaniumAlloy
46 - 5 - Shiro - Delf
47 - 5 - Barren Dunes - Lord_Pc
48 - 5 - Oasis - rafanest
49 - 5 - Palace - Crashnburn
50 - 5 - Temple of Light - theprawito
51 - 4 - Den - joe
52 - 4 - Forge - godstuffus
53 - 4 - Horde - godstuffus
54 - 4 - Planars - JortoBadfingrs
55 - 4 - Colony - DukeAchillus
56 - 4 - Demonificants - pug_1984
57 - 3 - Hyphae - Freeze_Dried
58 - 3 - Vocanos Rage - Pyromanzer
59 - 2 - Community - Blitzkrieg_Boy
60 - 2 - Fortress - NightFalcon
61 - 2 - Roost - dragonlord5555
62 - 2 - Engineers - kdahl
63 - 1 - Dinosaurians - sidtrix
64 - 1 - Aesir (Kingdom of North) - kdahl
65 - 1 - Wilderness - ManiaCCC
66 - 1 - Nomads - kdahl

Position - Race - Town - Author (All the extra points were applied here)

01 - 8,80 - Ziggurat - War-overlord
02 - 8,13 - Hollow - Kongo_Team
03 - 8,11 - Bastion - BoogieMan
04 - 8,10 - High Mountanins - caostotal_2000
05 - 8,06 - Beast-Alliance - Oakwarrior
06 - 8,00 - Stronghold of The North - rldragon
07 - 8,00 - Stronghold (by TDL) - TDL
08 - 7,94 - Saurian - Gnoll_Mage
09 - 7,93 - Cult - Lord-Kilburn
10 - 7,73 - Island - FriendOfGunnar
11 - 7,66 - Sanctuary - Blitzkrieg_Boy
12 - 7,56 - Burrows - Frakel
13 - 7,49 - Tomb - JJ_The_Ripper
14 - 7,47 - Azurin - AngelKiller
15 - 7,46 - Abyss - Foonlegacy
16 - 7,38 - Atlantis - gwyndolium
17 - 7,37 - Blood - godstuffus
18 - 7,31 - NarMai - Edenfer
19 - 7,29 - Artic Town - Author - TheNordicKing
20 - 7,28 - Cavern - kookastar
21 - 7,13 - Hive - UruramTururam
22 - 7,11 - Thundercrack - Phoenixzs
23 - 7,03 - Amatsu - orbvius
24 - 7,00 - Stoneblood - TitaniumAlloy
25 - 7,00 - Community - Blitzkrieg_Boy
26 - 6,97 - Glacier - Baklava
27 - 6,92 - Thaumaturges - molechular
28 - 6,89 - Hylozium - neko
29 - 6,83 - Imperial - Ulf
30 - 6,75 - Den - joe
31 - 6,73 - Civilization of the Deep - MasterSandro
32 - 6,62 - Shiro - Delf
33 - 6,56 - Vykavinco - Lord_Pc
34 - 6,55 - Warp - bloodandhonor
35 - 6,50 - Shrine - godstuffus
36 - 6,50 - Forge - godstuffus
37 - 6,43 - Confederation - diomed
38 - 6,37 - Permafrost - koshde
39 - 6,36 - Assaeroth - Shylock
40 - 6,33 - Wild - darkss
41 - 6,31 - High Wind Clan - admira
42 - 6,31 - Seerhome - fortress_fan
43 - 6,25 - Horde - godstuffus
44 - 6,25 - Stronghold - Gnoll_Mage
45 - 6,08 - Arctic Town - Author - Gerdash
46 - 5,94 - Asylum - Cheshire_Cat
47 - 5,60 - Barren Dunes - Lord_Pc
48 - 5,50 - Planars - JortoBadfingrs
49 - 5,40 - Colony - DukeAchillus
50 - 5,13 - Dwarven Mine - zombielordzero
51 - 5,00 - Demonificants - pug_1984
52 - 5,00 - Order of Sun - NightFalcon
53 - 5,00 - Hyphae - Freeze_Dried
54 - 4,75 - Swamp - Vinius
55 - 4,50 - Fortress - NightFalcon
56 - 4,33 - Tinkers - Gredinus
57 - 4,20 - Oasis - rafanest
58 - 3,80 - Palace - Crashnburn
59 - 3,64 - Temple of Light - theprawito
60 - 3,00 - Dinosaurians - sidtrix
61 - 3,00 - Aesir (Kingdom of North) - kdahl
62 - 2,00 - Wilderness - ManiaCCC
63 - 1,00 - Vocanos Rage - Pyromanzer
64 - 0,50 - Roost - dragonlord5555
65 - 0,00 - Engineers - kdahl
66 - 0,00 - Nomads - kdahl

Position - History - Town - Author

01 - 8,29 - Island - FriendOfGunnar
02 - 8,22 - Beast-Alliance - Oakwarrior
03 - 8,00 - Stronghold of The North - rldragon
04 - 7,97 - Ziggurat - War-overlord
05 - 7,93 - Tomb - JJ_The_Ripper
06 - 7,87 - Amatsu - orbvius
07 - 7,86 - NarMai - Edenfer
08 - 7,83 - Glacier - Baklava
09 - 7,77 - Cult - Lord-Kilburn
10 - 7,72 - High Mountanins - caostotal_2000
11 - 7,67 - Wild - darkss
12 - 7,65 - Assaeroth - Shylock
13 - 7,63 - Hollow - Kongo_Team
14 - 7,41 - Bastion - BoogieMan
15 - 7,36 - Burrows - Frakel
16 - 7,15 - Cavern - kookastar
17 - 7,12 - Sanctuary - Blitzkrieg_Boy
18 - 7,00 - Vykavinco - Lord_Pc
19 - 6,89 - Abyss - Foonlegacy
20 - 6,89 - Hylozium - neko
21 - 6,82 - Shiro - Delf
22 - 6,82 - Warp - bloodandhonor
23 - 6,66 - Civilization of the Deep - MasterSandro
24 - 6,50 - Imperial - Ulf
25 - 6,50 - Dwarven Mine - zombielordzero
26 - 6,43 - Stronghold (by TDL) - TDL
27 - 6,40 - Stoneblood - TitaniumAlloy
28 - 6,38 - High Wind Clan - admira
29 - 6,38 - Atlantis - gwyndolium
30 - 6,03 - Seerhome - fortress_fan
31 - 5,91 - Azurin - AngelKiller
32 - 5,80 - Thundercrack - Phoenixzs
33 - 5,72 - Saurian - Gnoll_Mage
34 - 5,62 - Artic Town - Author - TheNordicKing
35 - 5,50 - Hive - UruramTururam
36 - 5,50 - Shrine - godstuffus
37 - 5,45 - Permafrost - koshde
38 - 5,25 - Den - joe
39 - 5,25 - Demonificants - pug_1984
40 - 5,14 - Confederation - diomed
41 - 5,00 - Horde - godstuffus
42 - 5,00 - Order of Sun - NightFalcon
43 - 4,92 - Blood - godstuffus
44 - 4,88 - Stronghold - Gnoll_Mage
45 - 4,67 - Hyphae - Freeze_Dried
46 - 4,51 - Asylum - Cheshire_Cat
47 - 4,38 - Swamp - Vinius
48 - 4,20 - Barren Dunes - Lord_Pc
49 - 4,00 - Oasis - rafanest
50 - 3,84 - Temple of Light - theprawito
51 - 3,67 - Thaumaturges - molechular
52 - 3,15 - Colony - DukeAchillus
53 - 3,00 - Forge - godstuffus
54 - 3,00 - Fortress - NightFalcon
55 - 2,50 - Community - Blitzkrieg_Boy
56 - 2,50 - Roost - dragonlord5555
57 - 2,33 - Tinkers - Gredinus
58 - 2,08 - Arctic Town - Author - Gerdash
59 - 2,00 - Wilderness - ManiaCCC
60 - 1,33 - Vocanos Rage - Pyromanzer
61 - 1,00 - Palace - Crashnburn
62 - 0,00 - Planars - JortoBadfingrs
63 - 0,00 - Dinosaurians - sidtrix
64 - 0,00 - Engineers - kdahl
65 - 0,00 - Nomads - kdahl
66 - 0,00 - Aesir (Kingdom of North) - kdahl

Position - Creatures - Town - Author

01 - 9,00 - Community - Blitzkrieg_Boy
02 - 8,47 - Ziggurat - War-overlord
03 - 8,11 - Bastion - BoogieMan
04 - 8,03 - Cavern - kookastar
05 - 8,00 - Stronghold - Gnoll_Mage
06 - 7,94 - Saurian - Gnoll_Mage
07 - 7,88 - Hollow - Kongo_Team
08 - 7,87 - Blood - godstuffus
09 - 7,86 - Beast-Alliance - Oakwarrior
10 - 7,71 - Burrows - Frakel
11 - 7,71 - Confederation - diomed
12 - 7,70 - Sanctuary - Blitzkrieg_Boy
13 - 7,63 - Stronghold of The North - rldragon
14 - 7,61 - NarMai - Edenfer
15 - 7,54 - Glacier - Baklava
16 - 7,54 - High Wind Clan - admira
17 - 7,52 - Permafrost - koshde
18 - 7,51 - Island - FriendOfGunnar
19 - 7,47 - High Mountanins - caostotal_2000
20 - 7,28 - Atlantis - gwyndolium
21 - 7,23 - Civilization of the Deep - MasterSandro
22 - 7,20 - Amatsu - orbvius
23 - 7,20 - Stoneblood - TitaniumAlloy
24 - 7,18 - Artic Town - Author - TheNordicKing
25 - 7,17 - Thaumaturges - molechular
26 - 7,16 - Tomb - JJ_The_Ripper
27 - 7,14 - Abyss - Foonlegacy
28 - 7,13 - Hive - UruramTururam
29 - 7,00 - Horde - godstuffus
30 - 7,00 - Imperial - Ulf
31 - 7,00 - Vykavinco - Lord_Pc
32 - 6,93 - Cult - Lord-Kilburn
33 - 6,92 - Shiro - Delf
34 - 6,88 - Thundercrack - Phoenixzs
35 - 6,83 - Shrine - godstuffus
36 - 6,82 - Warp - bloodandhonor
37 - 6,78 - Hylozium - neko
38 - 6,71 - Stronghold (by TDL) - TDL
39 - 6,69 - Azurin - AngelKiller
40 - 6,60 - Oasis - rafanest
41 - 6,50 - Wild - darkss
42 - 6,50 - Den - joe
43 - 6,40 - Colony - DukeAchillus
44 - 6,38 - Arctic Town - Author - Gerdash
45 - 6,33 - Order of Sun - NightFalcon
46 - 6,31 - Seerhome - fortress_fan
47 - 6,22 - Assaeroth - Shylock
48 - 6,09 - Asylum - Cheshire_Cat
49 - 6,00 - Hyphae - Freeze_Dried
50 - 6,00 - Planars - JortoBadfingrs
51 - 5,80 - Barren Dunes - Lord_Pc
52 - 5,75 - Forge - godstuffus
53 - 5,60 - Palace - Crashnburn
54 - 5,50 - Swamp - Vinius
55 - 5,17 - Tinkers - Gredinus
56 - 5,00 - Dwarven Mine - zombielordzero
57 - 5,00 - Dinosaurians - sidtrix
58 - 4,84 - Temple of Light - theprawito
59 - 4,25 - Demonificants - pug_1984
60 - 4,00 - Fortress - NightFalcon
61 - 2,67 - Vocanos Rage - Pyromanzer
62 - 2,00 - Wilderness - ManiaCCC
63 - 0,50 - Roost - dragonlord5555
64 - 0,25 - Engineers - kdahl
65 - 0,00 - Nomads - kdahl
66 - 0,00 - Aesir (Kingdom of North) - kdahl

Position - Balance - Town - Author

01 - 9,00 - Community - Blitzkrieg_Boy
02 - 8,28 - Saurian - Gnoll_Mage
03 - 8,22 - Beast-Alliance - Oakwarrior
04 - 8,13 - Stronghold - Gnoll_Mage
05 - 8,01 - Bastion - BoogieMan
06 - 7,83 - Wild - darkss
07 - 7,75 - Horde - godstuffus
08 - 7,67 - Imperial - Ulf
09 - 7,57 - Stronghold (by TDL) - TDL
10 - 7,47 - Ziggurat - War-overlord
11 - 7,43 - Cult - Lord-Kilburn
12 - 7,38 - Stronghold of The North - rldragon
13 - 7,27 - Tomb - JJ_The_Ripper
14 - 7,25 - Hollow - Kongo_Team
15 - 7,17 - Shrine - godstuffus
16 - 7,06 - Permafrost - koshde
17 - 7,03 - Cavern - kookastar
18 - 7,01 - Civilization of the Deep - MasterSandro
19 - 7,01 - Burrows - Frakel
20 - 7,00 - Hyphae - Freeze_Dried
21 - 7,00 - Den - joe
22 - 6,97 - Glacier - Baklava
23 - 6,90 - Colony - DukeAchillus
24 - 6,90 - Artic Town - Author - TheNordicKing
25 - 6,82 - Blood - godstuffus
26 - 6,80 - Oasis - rafanest
27 - 6,80 - Asylum - Cheshire_Cat
28 - 6,75 - Forge - godstuffus
29 - 6,75 - Planars - JortoBadfingrs
30 - 6,60 - Seerhome - fortress_fan
31 - 6,57 - Confederation - diomed
32 - 6,55 - Warp - bloodandhonor
33 - 6,50 - Order of Sun - NightFalcon
34 - 6,50 - Swamp - Vinius
35 - 6,47 - Azurin - AngelKiller
36 - 6,46 - High Wind Clan - admira
37 - 6,42 - Thundercrack - Phoenixzs
38 - 6,40 - Island - FriendOfGunnar
39 - 6,40 - Palace - Crashnburn
40 - 6,38 - Hive - UruramTururam
41 - 6,37 - Amatsu - orbvius
42 - 6,33 - Hylozium - neko
43 - 6,33 - Vykavinco - Lord_Pc
44 - 6,28 - Atlantis - gwyndolium
45 - 6,16 - Sanctuary - Blitzkrieg_Boy
46 - 6,12 - Shiro - Delf
47 - 6,11 - NarMai - Edenfer
48 - 6,00 - Thaumaturges - molechular
49 - 6,00 - Barren Dunes - Lord_Pc
50 - 5,92 - Arctic Town - Author - Gerdash
51 - 5,89 - Abyss - Foonlegacy
52 - 5,75 - Dwarven Mine - zombielordzero
53 - 5,72 - High Mountanins - caostotal_2000
54 - 5,67 - Tinkers - Gredinus
55 - 5,60 - Stoneblood - TitaniumAlloy
56 - 5,51 - Assaeroth - Shylock
57 - 5,50 - Fortress - NightFalcon
58 - 5,04 - Temple of Light - theprawito
59 - 4,00 - Demonificants - pug_1984
60 - 2,67 - Vocanos Rage - Pyromanzer
61 - 2,00 - Wilderness - ManiaCCC
62 - 0,50 - Roost - dragonlord5555
63 - 0,00 - Engineers - kdahl
64 - 0,00 - Dinosaurians - sidtrix
65 - 0,00 - Nomads - kdahl
66 - 0,00 - Aesir (Kingdom of North) - kdahl

Position - Originality - Town - Author

01 - 9,00 - Community - Blitzkrieg_Boy
02 - 8,97 - Ziggurat - War-overlord
03 - 8,67 - Hylozium - neko
04 - 8,65 - Cavern - kookastar
05 - 8,51 - NarMai - Edenfer
06 - 8,42 - Amatsu - orbvius
07 - 8,40 - Island - FriendOfGunnar
08 - 8,14 - Confederation - diomed
09 - 8,13 - Hive - UruramTururam
10 - 8,01 - Civilization of the Deep - MasterSandro
11 - 8,00 - Forge - godstuffus
12 - 8,00 - Tinkers - Gredinus
13 - 7,89 - Sanctuary - Blitzkrieg_Boy
14 - 7,86 - Beast-Alliance - Oakwarrior
15 - 7,85 - High Mountanins - caostotal_2000
16 - 7,78 - Vykavinco - Lord_Pc
17 - 7,77 - Cult - Lord-Kilburn
18 - 7,75 - Hollow - Kongo_Team
19 - 7,71 - Bastion - BoogieMan
20 - 7,64 - Warp - bloodandhonor
21 - 7,50 - Shrine - godstuffus
22 - 7,43 - Stronghold (by TDL) - TDL
23 - 7,38 - High Wind Clan - admira
24 - 7,38 - Atlantis - gwyndolium
25 - 7,37 - Permafrost - koshde
26 - 7,36 - Burrows - Frakel
27 - 7,33 - Hyphae - Freeze_Dried
28 - 7,27 - Tomb - JJ_The_Ripper
29 - 7,25 - Den - joe
30 - 7,25 - Thaumaturges - molechular
31 - 7,17 - Saurian - Gnoll_Mage
32 - 7,17 - Imperial - Ulf
33 - 7,15 - Colony - DukeAchillus
34 - 7,12 - Blood - godstuffus
35 - 7,12 - Shiro - Delf
36 - 6,97 - Glacier - Baklava
37 - 6,97 - Assaeroth - Shylock
38 - 6,88 - Stronghold of The North - rldragon
39 - 6,75 - Stronghold - Gnoll_Mage
40 - 6,72 - Thundercrack - Phoenixzs
41 - 6,71 - Arctic Town - Author - Gerdash
42 - 6,60 - Stoneblood - TitaniumAlloy
43 - 6,50 - Planars - JortoBadfingrs
44 - 6,34 - Artic Town - Author - TheNordicKing
45 - 6,20 - Palace - Crashnburn
46 - 6,20 - Barren Dunes - Lord_Pc
47 - 6,17 - Wild - darkss
48 - 6,17 - Order of Sun - NightFalcon
49 - 6,14 - Abyss - Foonlegacy
50 - 6,13 - Azurin - AngelKiller
51 - 6,00 - Oasis - rafanest
52 - 5,89 - Seerhome - fortress_fan
53 - 5,75 - Horde - godstuffus
54 - 5,66 - Asylum - Cheshire_Cat
55 - 5,50 - Dwarven Mine - zombielordzero
56 - 5,25 - Demonificants - pug_1984
57 - 5,25 - Engineers - kdahl
58 - 4,50 - Fortress - NightFalcon
59 - 4,13 - Swamp - Vinius
60 - 3,67 - Vocanos Rage - Pyromanzer
61 - 3,64 - Temple of Light - theprawito
62 - 3,00 - Dinosaurians - sidtrix
63 - 2,00 - Wilderness - ManiaCCC
64 - 1,00 - Nomads - kdahl
65 - 0,50 - Roost - dragonlord5555
66 - 0,00 - Aesir (Kingdom of North) - kdahl
____________
"Parve leves capiunt animos."

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
panduwana
panduwana


Adventuring Hero
posted February 06, 2006 05:49 PM
Edited by panduwana on 6 Feb 2006

Nice, makes it easier for people who want to root for underdogs
Hey, since you are wandering to all ICTC threads, please notify me if any proposal get disqualified or any other status change or anything, thanks.

Good luck with the ratings everyone.

Uhm, suggestion: maybe you can improve the spacing, so it will be easier to read which score for which entry.

____________

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
Oakwarrior
Oakwarrior


Famous Hero
posted February 06, 2006 06:02 PM

Dont leave a space before the Average Score thingy

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
MasterSandro
MasterSandro


posted February 06, 2006 06:04 PM

My proposal of the Brutes was disqualified for some reason, it can't be here anymore... But the civilization of the deep isn't. How are we supposed to vote? just replying the proposals?

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
Oakwarrior
Oakwarrior


Famous Hero
posted February 06, 2006 06:10 PM

Well, you read the ITIC entry, then vote
There are instructions in the beginning of this forum.

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
frakel
frakel


Adventuring Hero
posted February 06, 2006 06:23 PM

Great idea!

Makes it all the more exciting - and makes sure none is left behind with zero votes (I hope)

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
panduwana
panduwana


Adventuring Hero
posted February 06, 2006 06:27 PM
Edited by panduwana on 6 Feb 2006

Quote:
Dont leave a space before the Average Score thingy

Yeah maybe it's like this:

TownName VoteNumber: Race - Hist - Crit - Bal - Orig
TotalScore
(blank line)

so the list will look like this:



Atrium 8 votes: ------- Race 7.5 ------- Hist 8.25 ------- Crit 9.1 ------- Bal 8.8 ------- Orig 6.9
Average Score 7.8

Basement 1 votes: ------- Race 7 ------- Hist 8 ------- Crit 9 ------- Bal 8 ------- Orig 6
Average Score 7.8

Ceiling 2 votes: ------- Race 7.5 ------- Hist 8.5 ------- Crit 9.0 ------- Bal 8.5 ------- Orig 5.0
Average Score 7.0

Dining Room 0 votes: ------- Race 0 ------- Hist 0 ------- Crit 0 ------- Bal 0 ------- Orig 0
Average Score N/A



(since we don't have table)

____________

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
Oakwarrior
Oakwarrior


Famous Hero
posted February 06, 2006 06:33 PM

That fits the bill nicely

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
miru
miru


Supreme Hero
A leaf in the river of time
posted February 07, 2006 05:51 AM

How does asylum have no votes, but it does have score?
____________
I wish I were employed by a stupendous paragraph, with capitalized English words and expressions.

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
Oakwarrior
Oakwarrior


Famous Hero
posted February 07, 2006 04:30 PM
Edited by Oakwarrior on 7 Feb 2006

O.o

I'm on the lead with a whopping 0.25 at the moment

EDIT:

Suggestion:
Add the author's name after the entry

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
Gredinus
Gredinus


posted February 07, 2006 05:02 PM

Tinkers vote result:
Oakwarrior; R=6,H=7,C=8,B=7,O=9  total=37
MasterSandro; R=6,H=2,C=4,B=6,O=9  total=27

ALLtogeather= 32

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
BoogieMan
BoogieMan


Famous Hero
The John of Spades
posted February 08, 2006 06:04 PM

I will not read this thread, as I don't want anything to affect the ratings I give. I also don't read the other ratings a town has, until I am finished writing my own ratings. I recommend this practice to everyone.
____________
The BoogieMan wrote ... and saw that it was good.

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
Oakwarrior
Oakwarrior


Famous Hero
posted February 08, 2006 06:10 PM

IMO, this is mainly for the judges for easy and quick reference.

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
zombielordzero
zombielordzero

Tavern Dweller
posted February 08, 2006 07:29 PM

looks like i'm out, average score ~27, highest score ~42
not bad for 1/2 a day effort (feb 3rd no less).
____________

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
BoogieMan
BoogieMan


Famous Hero
The John of Spades
posted February 08, 2006 08:49 PM

Quote:
IMO, this is mainly for the judges for easy and quick reference.


The judges must calculate the ratings themselves. I for one have gone back on a few towns and changed my ratings (although by 1-2 points max), trying to be as fair as possible, so this thread may turn out to be inexact unless recalculated from scratch each day.
____________
The BoogieMan wrote ... and saw that it was good.

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
JJ_The_Ripper
JJ_The_Ripper


Adventuring Hero
addicted HOMM player
posted February 09, 2006 10:53 AM

Quote:
... so this thread may turn out to be inexact unless recalculated from scratch each day.


It is very hard to update every score every day. The main idea of this thread is to help ICTC town owners to follow the evollution of their town.
Regards,
JJ

____________
"Parve leves capiunt animos."

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
BoogieMan
BoogieMan


Famous Hero
The John of Spades
posted February 09, 2006 11:37 AM

All I'm saying is that it may cause some people to give biased ratings. Already, there is a disturbing phenomenon happening: friend votes. Some people just come on in and give an awesome rating to their friends' towns then don't even bother to view other entries. I guess this is, after all, inevitable - there's nothing anyone can do about it - you can force people to rate all 60 towns, but it's a matter of fair-play and respect.

No offence, I know you are actually trying to help and yes, you may be sparing some people the arithmetic effort but I'm just saying you're involuntarily opening a little crack for even more biased votes with this thread, something we could do without.


____________
The BoogieMan wrote ... and saw that it was good.

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
Edenfer
Edenfer


Hired Hero
posted February 09, 2006 07:06 PM

I agree with Boogie man here i saw a lot of strange comments in the ratings that i felt were partly due to this post. I prefer this competition to remain friendly and fun !


 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
JJ_The_Ripper
JJ_The_Ripper


Adventuring Hero
addicted HOMM player
posted February 09, 2006 07:22 PM

Quote:
I agree with Boogie man here i saw a lot of strange comments in the ratings that i felt were partly due to this post. I prefer this competition to remain friendly and fun !




To be honest, I think that the ratings comments in the town's threads do more harm than this thread. To be completly fair everyone should post only numbers...
Any comment may influence someone's rating. But that depends on the person that it is votting.
You can always not to look
Regards,
JJ
____________
"Parve leves capiunt animos."

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
frakel
frakel


Adventuring Hero
posted February 10, 2006 12:18 AM
Edited by frakel on 9 Feb 2006

Quote:

To be honest, I think that the ratings comments in the town's threads do more harm than this thread. To be completly fair everyone should post only numbers...
Any comment may influence someone's rating. But that depends on the person that it is votting.
You can always not to look
Regards,
JJ


I dont know... In principle I think it is ok for reviewers to try and influence each other. Someone might notice a nice detail, or a balancing problem and make others aware of it. I think this is ok as long as the person giving the rating makes up his own mind. Nobody is bound to follow the rating trend made by the first reviewers of a town - but I admit it is a problem if people start to look more at previous votes and comments than the actual town entry itself.

Quote:

I for one have gone back on a few towns and changed my ratings (although by 1-2 points max), trying to be as fair as possible


This is very nice! When you grade more towns and get to learn more, the basis of previous grades are constantly changed. None of my grades are final before the bell rings for the end of voting...


Best of luck to everyone!


____________

 Send Instant Message | Send E-Mail | View Profile | Quote Reply | Link
Jump To: « Prev Thread . . . Next Thread » This thread is 2 pages long: 1 2 · NEXT»
Post New Poll    Post New Topic    Post New Reply

Page compiled in 0.3593 seconds